This is a test of GDPR / Cookie Acceptance [about our cookies]
Really irritating test - cookie expires in 24 hour!
Terrible signalling error!
As at 6th January 2025 20:11 GMT
 
Terrible signalling error!
Posted by JayMac at 10:45, 26th December 2024
 
I've just been watching the docudrama about the notorious master of disguise and jewel thief Feathers McGraw, and his attempt to again steal the fabled Blue Diamond. While making his escape on a goods train I noticed this semaphore signal.



The signal is 'off' but the red spectacle is in front of the lamp. <shakes head>

Oh and Feathers is on the last wagon of an unfitted goods train. Where's the brake van?

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Oxonhutch at 11:24, 26th December 2024
 
More importantly, where is the tail lamp?

A lower quadrant in the upper quadrant!! Spotted that yesterday.

Family called me a nerd

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Mark A at 11:45, 26th December 2024
 
'Feathers' should be allowed no where near a railway line and will already have done for the brake van. Also, the upper quadrant / red light... that is possibly an easter egg put in for the likes of coffeeshoppers to find and the forum has not fallen short on that count.

Mark

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Ralph Ayres at 12:28, 26th December 2024
 
Hadn't spotted the anomalous signal light. Think I might have to watch it again as there was far too much detail to take it all in at one viewing, and I was still chuckling from the "No parkin" sign at the Yorkshire border.

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Electric train at 12:36, 26th December 2024
 
Hadn't spotted the anomalous signal light. Think I might have to watch it again as there was far too much detail to take it all in at one viewing, and I was still chuckling from the "No parkin" sign at the Yorkshire border.

unfitted freight should have a brake van.

But I don't wish to take away from what is an excellent Wallace and Grommet film

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by JayMac at 12:45, 26th December 2024
 
It was an excellent bit of Christmas telly.

So many great gags for us big kids to delight in. I particularly enjoyed the canal boat 'chase'.

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by TonyK at 15:39, 26th December 2024
 
It was an excellent bit of Christmas telly.

So many great gags for us 'big kids to delight in. I particularly enjoyed the canal boat 'chase'.

The "Yorkshire Border - Keep Out" sign was one thing. The Lancashire side's "No, You Keep Out" showed insider knowledge.

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by johnneyw at 15:44, 26th December 2024
 
It was the white seal pup on Feather McGraw's lap, Blofeld style, that nearly had me spitting out my Gluhwein.

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by PhilWakely at 16:46, 26th December 2024
 
Very lazy signalman! The signal arm was still raised after the train disappeared into the tunnel!

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Chris from Nailsea at 22:21, 26th December 2024
 

Family called me a nerd


I do sympathise, Oxonhutch. 

I, too, get a load of grief from my wife and daughter when I mutter about such 'errors' in television programmes. 


Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Oxonhutch at 22:40, 26th December 2024
 
I do sympathise, Oxonhutch. 

I, too, get a load of grief from my wife and daughter when I mutter about such 'errors' in television programmes. 

Many years ago there was a programme about Mozart, and he boarded a train in Vienna for Moscow. When he arrived in the same carriage in the Russian capital I cried BS!!

On universal disapproval, the nerd informed the perplexed and annoyed family that the gauge changed at the Polish border. I was not popular.

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Kempis at 08:32, 27th December 2024
 
Many years ago there was a programme about Mozart, and he boarded a train in Vienna for Moscow. When he arrived in the same carriage in the Russian capital I cried BS!!

On universal disapproval, the nerd informed the perplexed and annoyed family that the gauge changed at the Polish border. I was not popular.

There could be a more fundamental inconsistency there. Mozart died in 1791, and according to Wikipedia the first main line railway in Austria opened in 1837.

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Oxonhutch at 09:40, 27th December 2024
 
There could be a more fundamental inconsistency there. Mozart died in 1791, and according to Wikipedia the first main line railway in Austria opened in 1837.

I think you can see, I know my railways better than my composers!

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Kempis at 15:06, 27th December 2024
 
I think you can see, I know my railways better than my composers!

Could it have been Tchaikovsky? I’m posting on my phone, and so can’t easily provide a link, but I believe he visited Vienna several times between 1870 and 1892, by which time the railways were operating.

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Western Pathfinder at 16:45, 27th December 2024
 
Sitting watching it on the day I remarked about the lack of a tail lamp !
And was greeted by a chorus of Trust You....

Re: Terrible signalling error!
Posted by Witham Bobby at 12:05, 30th December 2024
 
The only thing about this film that I disliked was this.  Grated badly.  Family unimpressed with my reaction

 
The Coffee Shop forum is provided by customers of Great Western Railway (formerly First Great Western). The views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit https://www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that the content provided by one of our posters contravenes our posting rules ( graham AT sn12.net ).

Although we are planning ahead, we don't know what the future will bring here in the Coffee Shop. We have domains "firstgreatwestern.info" for w-a-y back and also "greatwesternrailway.info"; we can also answer to "greatbritishrailways.info" too. For the future, information about Great Brisish Railways, by customers and for customers.
 
Current Running
GWR trains from JourneyCheck
 
 
Code Updated 3rd January 2025